LA HAINE ESSAY PLANS
examinez les similarités et les différences entre Saïd, vinz et hubert - CORRECT ANSWER-SIMILARITIES: VIOLENCE - they are all
... [Show More] violent, and this is shown in different ways, physically and verbally. eg DIFFERENCES: AMBITION - hubert has ambition (to open a gym) and realises the banlieues are toxic "j'en ai marre de cette cité, il faut que je parte d'ici". saïd and vinz show no ambition SIMILARITIES: LIVING CONDITIONS (EXCLUDED) - "on vit dans des trous à rats", scenes with graffiti in background DIFFERENCES: ETHNICITY - Saïd est arab, Hubert est noir et Vinz est juif, représentations of parisien banlieues after war
expliquez comment sont présentés les trois personnages principaux au début du film et ce que l'audience apprend sur eux - CORRECT ANSWER-Kassovitz utilise les gros plans... SAÏD - is introduced first. is shown graffitiing the police van "baise la police" shows straight away his hatred for police, shouts to Vinz's bedroom - no consideration for the neighbours, argues with neighbours VINZ - shown in bedroom acting as a 'badboy' he has a knuckleduster which hints at a gangster side to him HUBERT - first shown in the gym which immediately tells the viewer that he has more ambition than the others
dans la haine, MK a réussi à dépeindre l'exclusion sociale. etes-vous d'accord? - CORRECT ANSWER-EXCLUDED BY POLICE - police constantly surveilling, the scene on roof. LIVING IN THE BANLIEUES - reveals fracture sociale, "on vit dans des trous à rats", identity of the cite in contrast to in Paris, 'un de nous' (Said describing Abdel), feeling of belonging BY THE MEDIA - "on n'est pas à Thoiry ici" the scene with journalists ETHNIC MINORITIES - "un Arab", abuse of power from police in Paris, driven by racism
examinez les trois personnages et comment ils inspirent de la sympathie chez les spectateurs - CORRECT ANSWER-HUBERT - although he sells drugs, we sympathise because he is shown later giving the money to his mum to pay for the bills, caring VINZ - although he steals the gun, it is clear to the viewer that he does this to try and maintain power. it is obvious that he is too good to actually kill someone, and so the viewer can sympathise, driven by friend Abdel SAÏD - he seems much less confident than the other two and this shows his vulnerable side FAMILY - caring towards women in their family, said is rude to women in Paris contrats to worrying about his sister, Vinz wants to choose the right colour peppers
examinez jusqu'a quel point les trois personnages principauz sont des personnages réalistes ou des stéréotypes - CORRECT ANSWER-REALISTIC - the banlieues often
housed immigrants and their descendants and so a group of 3 different races is not unrealistic, representation of Parsi after was STEREOTYPE - verbally violent, seen in scene with journalists (reminder of misrepresentation) or 'nique ta mere', rude to women REALISTIC - people in the banlieues tended to act that way in order to gain respect. STEREOTYPE - Vinz as a gangster, possessing a gun, echoes of 'Taxi Driver' in mirror scene
analysez l'importance des épisodes et les évènements les plus importants de l'histoire - CORRECT ANSWER-JOURNALISTS SCENE - shows that the three are seen as violent people, media misrepresents "on n'est pas à Thoiry ici" SITTING DOING NOTHING - shows the boredom they experience in daily life, graffiti in background WITH THE SKINHEADS - shows that Vinz cannot kill someone, he realises he wont be able to kill a police officer, appearance of a bad boy VINZ GETS KILLED - he is killed ironically by accident. Hubert is the one who has the gun just when Vinz actually needs it, leitmotiv of film repeated, vicious circle
examinez les actions et les évènements dans le film et comment ils reflèchent l'affirmation que la haine attire la haine - CORRECT ANSWER-LA FIN - Vinz steals a gun and gets shot by one, vicious circle of hatred between jeunes et la police MOTIVATED BY ABDEL/POLICE BAUVRE: verbally violent to police resulting from initial physical violence LIFE IN SUBURBS: the scene on the roof, restriction and feelings of surveillance BEHAVIOUR: Hubert's ambition at start vs the ending with gun
analysez la représentation de la vie en banlieue dans ce film. dans quelle mesure est-ce que c'est une représentation justifée? - CORRECT ANSWER-REAL LIFE - the police brutality resulting in the death of Makome M'bowole PRIVACY - scene du DJ, Said shouting at start DELINQUENCY - take drugs, graffiti, riot "le boss dans le cité" when Vinz has the gun, hierarchies in the cite HOPELESSNESS - Hubert realises theres no hope in the banlieues and wants to leave (ambitions)
le titre du film LA HAINE est bien choisi car il reflète exactement le thème principal du film" dans quelle mesure êtes-vous d'accord avec ce jugement? - CORRECT ANSWER-VIOLENCE - violence is installed in the daily lives of the trio, seen in Paris, racism REVENGE - "la haine attire la haine" Vinz plans to shoot a police officer and he gets shot by one in the end LES JOURNALISTS: hatred in form of exclusion BAUVRE POLICIERE: the film initiated from real events
examinez la répresentation de la police dans ce film - CORRECT ANSWER-REAL LIFE - the police brutality resulting in the death of Makome M'bowole
PARIS - Said & Hubert arrested, violently molested, abuse of power & racism LA FIN - 'oubliez pas que la police tue', we feel as if the police are constantly supervising on the estate (on the roofs, scenes where they walk past the trio, feelings of tension) KINDNESS - vouvoie in Paris & the role of Samir, feels as if he is there to help & protect
analysez le rapport entre les jeunes des banlieues et la police - CORRECT ANSWER- [Show Less]